Basement Systems estimate I received...

[djbauda]

Here are the problems I'm having with my unfinished, poured concrete basement:
1. effloresence on walls throughout basement
2. water stains on one corner of floor
3. existing french drain system with non-working sump pit (filled with construction debris from before I moved in). drains are also not angled properly
4. white mold on some of the wood in the ceiling
5. previous owner painted walls - paint is now lifting off - further signs of moisture

I had a representative from Basement Systems come out and he recommended the following:
1. install waterguard product
2. install airtight sump
3. install sanidry system
4. spray to treat mold ($600)
5. install window well drains

The price was rather high but I am really impressed with his knowledge as well as the company's reputation. However, I think I can save a ton of money if I just do the following:
1. replace the existing sump pump with an airtight one
2. put a dehumidifier in one corner of the basement and another in the opposite corner. have them set up to automatically drain
3. spray to remove the mold
4. install window well covers
5. snake the existing french drains to remove any clogged dirt/mud/etc

So, here are my questions:
1. Why shouldn't I go with the approach I suggested above?
2. What is the benefit of the sanidry system over my two dehumidifiers? The sanidry system is rated for up to 2500sq feet. I only need it for about 800 sq feet so this system might be overkill.

Please let me know if anyone can further assist. Thanks.

[Basement MD]

I think what the Basement Systems dealer was proposing was to offer the best solution avalable for your basement and your needs.

The SaniDry is one of the best rated Dehumidifiers on the market with the Best Energy Star rating. It also has a filter system that takes particles out of the air down to two microns.

You would also get a Waterwatch alarm on the sump, floor drain, IceGuard and airtight top. You also have a system that has already failed, you can't be certain of its condition if you just snake the drains. You will also recieve a warranty with the Basement Systems Dealer.
Good Luck

[djbauda]

Thanks for the reply. I haven't made up my mind yet, but I have to say that I am thoroughly impressed with this company and the representative that came to my house. I had three other companies give me estimates and none of them knew as much about their products or spent as much time with me as Basement Systems.

Thanks again.
Dan